View Single Post
  #85 (permalink)  
Old 12-21-2007
daisym daisym is offline
Vice President

 
Member Since: Mar 2004
Location: Australia
Posts: 7,550

   
Re: Watson threatens to ram Jap whalers.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Si modo View Post
So, it's hard to tell, do you advocate the deliberate ramming of these vessels?

I'm wondering why you make this statement, unless you think persons who participated in this thread have any comfort with respect to killing whales.
I'd be interested to know what 'ramming' would entail.

The only 'ramming' I know of WRT recent events in Japanese whaling was when the whaling ship (much bigger than a greenpeace ship) rammed a greenpeace boat.

Usually greenpeace come between the whale and the boat, preventing the whalers from - what I can only call murdering - the whales. (as I mentioned above - the cruel and unusal method of killing cannot be compared to methods used to kill other animals for food).

While I agree with Kijana that ramming another boat in any circumstances should be avoided, and especially in the icy waters of the antarctic (and I know people who fish those oceans - and IMHO you've got to be mad to go there in any case), I'm not really sure that what we are talking about here is all that dangerous. Its more a protest - and a symbolic protest.

I guess however after being rammed for coming between whalers and a minke whale, its not surprising that Greenpeace might talk about ramming. Better to be the rammer than the rammee - and if the whalers are going to ram greenpeace for coming between the whale and the harpoon - I'd be fully on the side of ramming the whaler.
Reply With Quote