In my little middle of nowhere village, where I sit on the city council, am known on a first name basis with the city Clerk and sign the paycheck for the police chief and I was asked for ID to vote.

The only issue I can see with this ruling in its practical application is accounting for someone who recently lost thier ID somehow. I dont think it unreasonable to ask for photo ID. But, if I lost my wallet over the weekend and the election is on Tuesday, well I think everyone can see a potential problem there.

__________________
Abstinence Education at its finest: