View Single Post
  #23 (permalink)  
Old 05-13-2008
TSGracchus TSGracchus is offline
Secretary of Defense

 
Member Since: Jun 2005
Location: San Francisco Bay Area
Posts: 3,200

   
Re: What if America had stayed out of WWI?

Quote:
Originally Posted by goober View Post
Clearly Austria started the war, by declaring war on Serbia.
So the Axis forces were the aggressors.
Germany had already mobilized their forces in the west.
There was plenty of gung-ho warmongering all around. Austria declared war on Serbia, yes, but that didn't automatically involve Russia, Germany, France, Britain, Italy, the Ottoman Empire, Japan, or the United States. Each nation was responsible for its own behavior, and as best I can see they all went whacko. Germany must bear her share of the blame, but so must France, Britain, and Russia. As for German mobilization, this was done in anticipation of a French declaration of war, which the French duly provided. There are a number of unpleasant things one can say about German behavior during the war, such as violation of Belgian neutrality and the execution of innocent hostages after sabotage or guerrilla attacks, but it's going too far to accuse any one nation of "starting the war."

A good book on the subject is Barbara Tuchman's The Guns of August. The description of French attitudes alone is revealing. The French were thirsting for revenge for 1870. A common graffitum in Paris was "Quarante-Huitante" ("Forty-Eighty"), with the implication that as there were 40 million Frenchmen and eighty million Germans, if every Frenchman killed two Germans Germany would be annihilated.
Reply With Quote