Quote:
Originally Posted by Fennica
-¤Tibetian are not kin to the chinese, yes?(to any of the many kin there)
¤Do they have the same customs and traditions?(in other words, culture.)
¤Do they have the same language, and similar mindset?
If answers are "no", then Tibet is not part of China through anything but aggression.
|
there are 56 ethnics in China(textbook,in fact,there are more than 56 ethnics in China).Tibetan is one of them,as other ethnic,they have different skin.i had asked a westerner how does he define "Tibetan"? if one natvie born in Tibet,then he is Tibetan?say again,most muslims live in Tibet since Tang dynasty--thousand years ago,they are not buddhists,they have not same skin as buddhists(most muslims don't get marry with buddhists in China,most muslims don't get marry with antitheist).are they Tibetan? yes ,of course they are Tibetan.
and say again,Tibetan buddhists natives,most of them don't think they are belong to one ethnic,in the south of Tibet--near India,some natives strongly hate Dalai Lama,when Dalai Lama have a speech in there,some Tibetan went there to protest Dalai.they have different face too.how do you feel them?should they separte with Tibet?just because they have different skin and religion belief.
you logic is fail
in China,in every province,people have different customs and traditions.for example,in Shan Xi,native muslims have their own customs,they in white hat.but in Bei Jing and Kai Feng(He Nan province),muslisms in red hat.in some area of China,muslims in blue hat. they have different customs,they live in different province,but they are belong to one ethnic-Hui.
by your logic,should Bei Jing and He Nan separte with China?
I can say Madarin,but in my home town--locate in Ru Chen county,Chen Zhou,Hu Nan province,there are two local language,one language is Hakas,I can say Hakas,this is my mother lanaguage,and i can say another dialect.i studied Madarin in school,i studies English in school.after i left School,i went to Shen Zhen--I am still here.the Natives speak Hakas too.but few of them speak Cantonese,i can say a little Cantonese(but not too much)
should my hometown separate with China?because we don't speak Madarin when we were born.
by the way,in Tibet,there are much local language too.for example,Tibetan in Lasa speak one language,but in other place,Tibetan speak other language,when Lasa Tibetan go to Ah-Ba,Shi Chuan province(there are four ethnics live in there,Tibetan is one of them).they can't talk with Native Tibetan.
so,i suggest you had better learn more about China.
if just people have different skin,custom,language,then China should be separated.then that's too funny.there's no pure one ethnic country in this world.different ethnic must love each other,but not kill others.
in Gui Zhou province,in Yun Nan province,there are many ethnics live together,but they don't kill each other,they live peaceful.
in China,actually,people concern with this: do you have enough ability to do work.but don't care which ethnic r u belong to.