View Single Post
  #63 (permalink)  
Old 01-11-2009
solletica's Avatar
solletica solletica is offline
Secretary of State

 
Member Since: Dec 2005
Location: USA
Posts: 3,535

   
Re: Dr. Gupta, I Presume!

Quote:
Originally Posted by Tanngrisnir3 View Post
[/b]

Again, you offer zero support for anything in your last, bolded paragraph. Cite some statistics for specialist MD's w/and w/out PhD and let the data fall where it will, or stop embarassing yourself.
Part of a specialist's job is diagnosis. The ability to diagnose accurately depends on one's ability to apply existing knowledge to form a conclusion and/or to order further relevant tests to isolate it and/or to do additional research.

The ability to do this can only be required through original research experience. And unfortunately, the M. D. degree doesn't even require it.

Medical school (and residency/intern) training at best only drills a bunch of facts/procedures into the student's head. And that doesn't cut it. When it comes time to diagnose a condition, unless that M. D. is very lucky (the diagnosis was one that was drilled into his head via memorization of specific procedures, he'll be SOL.

But if it was that simple (i. e. diagnosis thru memorization) a doctor wouldn't even be needed. Test/radiology results + WebMD would do
__________________