View Single Post
  #89 (permalink)  
Old 01-11-2009
solletica's Avatar
solletica solletica is offline
Secretary of State

 
Member Since: Dec 2005
Location: USA
Posts: 3,535

   
Re: Dr. Gupta, I Presume!

Quote:
Originally Posted by Sunshine View Post
Whoa, I better call us Vanderbilt and let them in on this!

An MD does not have to also have a PhD to practice in a specialty. They don't even have to be board certified in that specialty unless it is required by the practice he works in.
Those are only the legal requirements, as I've said over and over and over. But simply meeting the legal requirement to practice isn't enough to qualify one as a real doctor, just as simply being elected/appointed Pres is insufficient to qualify one as a real leader.

In terms of the Ph. D., I already recanted that requirement, saying that any kind of original work or research, with or without a Ph. D. is a requirement to be considered a true doctor. But the original work is a hard requirement. If one doesn't have it, he/she cannot be called a doctor.

Someone who treats patients in an area is inevitably going to encounter medical conditions with which he/she is unfamiliar. At that point, that's where the original thinking/research comes in. A person who has no experience with that will fail at that point, and consequently, many of these "doctors" do.

I could cite the stats showing the no. of suits filed due to misdiagnoses or erroneous treatments.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Sunshine View Post
Most who do get some kind of PhD work at university hospitals and they can go to school for free. It's part of their employment package.
They can but they won't, which I've already pointed out, because there's no immediate financial incentive. A neurosurgeon w/no Ph. D. will make $450-$700k/yr. With a Ph. D. and/or publications, he'll make the same, unless he/she can successfully market that doctorate to differentiate himself, enough to justify not contracting w/insurance cos.

At that point, a neurosurgeon can make several million a year.
__________________