Quote:
Originally Posted by O'Sullivan Bere
Very, very rarely--this is the 4th out of thousands. And this was a 5-4 split decision, which shows her line of thinking on this case wasn't without foundation given the District Court and Second Circuit Court of Appeal panel agreed with her as well as 4 of the SCOTUS Justices, and in the very few she has been reversed, a heavily split SCOTUS also appeared. Her record insofar as reversals is outstanding.
|
Did you hear the desenting remarks made by Ruth Ginsberg? She actually stated "We sympathise" with the men (white & latinos) who passed this test--but were denied promotions.
People do end up in the Supreme court to obtain SYMPATHY. They are there for JUSTICE.
It's apparent that the desenting judges--were more concerned with the city getting sued -- versus following the LAW according to the U.S constitution.
This is VERY bad for Sotomayer. This is now the 4th decision she has made that did not make it through the U.S supreme court.
I was holding my decision--to see what the supreme court would do--now I am against her appointment to the U.S Supreme court.