Quote:
Originally Posted by Maat222
And why does Israel have any right to exist?
The land Israel is built on was occupied by millions of Arabs, who were killed or driven off.
How is that not a crime?
You are justified in attacking women and children when they impose a threat to the continuation of your entire culture, they are illegally and knowingly occupying what is yours, and no other alternative is available.
Yes the US probably deserved the 9/11 attack, because of crimes we committed; but the attack on civilians was not necessary, so was not justified.
But Iran has done nothing wrong, so no attack on Iran would be justified.
Attacking those speaking out is never justified.
|
OK. So Israel doesn't have a right to exist, rocket attacks against civilians are justified. And
"the US probably deserved the 9/11 attack".
Thanks for explaining your point of view. Now we can all see what your idea of justice looks like.
I loved how he ended up justifying the attacks of 9/11 and then condemning them in the same sentence. That was great!
And for the record, since this thread is supposedly about Jews who support removing settlements, there are many Jews (Rabbis or just your average Israelis like me) who are for removing most or all the settlements. A few years ago we saw all the settlements from Gaza removed by Israel, and several settlements in the West Bank as well. But have we seen any gestures from the Palestinian side after that? No, we just got more rockets and more demands. So forgive us if Israel is a little cautious about making further withdrawals.
We are going to remove some settlements, but only in keeping with our security concerns. We're not going to just remove all the settlements at once. We’re going to take it slow to see whether at any point the Palestinians do decide to start moving forward perhaps reciprocating with a few peaceful gestures of their own. We’re willing to move forward with the peace process if they’re willing to do their part. But incitement to violence, rocket attacks and refusal to compromise, really aren’t conducive to peace.
To put it simply, it takes two to tango. And Israel has shown in the past that when we have a real partner on the other side peace is possible.