Quote:
Originally Posted by TheStripey1
The Japanese government has refused to do anything about it. They were the ones that forced the women into the brothels. Why do you think the US should apologize? and goodfella? There have been brothels in war zones for as long as there have been wars. Should we apologize for all of them?
|
First, the US government and military's involvement with regards to the brothels is not 100% clear as the article suggests. At a minimum, the US was complicit to the extent that tacit approval was given -- the issue of whether or not the US KNEW about this is not in question. At worst, we were passive participants who looked the other way.
Did I say that we should apologize for every brothel ever created? No. Please don't put words in my mouth.
Further, this situation refers to the period of US occupation in Japan which is clearly POST-WAR. So this "well war is hell and shit happens" excuse doesn't apply. Further, what is clear with regards to these so-called "comfort women" is that many if not most of these women who served in these so-called "brothels" were women of both Japanese and other Asian nationalities who were taken against their will from countries that Japan occupied. These weren't "whores" looking to make a quick buck. These were innocent victims of war perpetrated by a brutal imperial army with an official policy for the creation of sex slaves to service the Japanese imperial army. This was absolutely a crime against humanity by an reasonable measure. If the US was a willing partner and helped perpetuate this policy post-war, then yes, we ABSOLUTELY need to apologize for it. To what extent is unclear as I said before.
Even it it WERE in a time of war, are you saying that since things such as rape and murder happen in a time of war "we should not give a shit"?
Why should we apologize? Please re-read my comments in post #29.
Quote:
|
This is clearly a situation which we must examine and, if warranted, apologize for.
|
I believe this is a situation which must be examined further. Once the facts become clear, and if warranted, the US should apologize.