View Single Post
  #166 (permalink)  
Old 05-08-2007
JHC's Avatar
JHC JHC is offline
President
a cold, cold woman... and junebug sympathizer

 
Member Since: Dec 2004
Location: Florida US
Posts: 10,538

United_States     Wyoming

Re: Supreme Court upholds Partial Birth Abortion Ban

Quote:
Originally Posted by Dilettante View Post
I think (and correct me if I'm wrong) you're refering to post #111. I fail to see how crushing the skull after it emerged could possibly benefit the woman in any of those cases. If you know of a way, I am willing to hear you out.

The Dr. you mention was defending the necessity of some late-term abotions, not this particular procedure and certainly not the final, grisly act that makes it so disturbing.

Please don't misunderstand me, I'm perfectly willing to acknowledge that late-term abortions might rarely be necessary to save the mother's life/health. Any broad-based ban on them should have to include such an exception.



And in the absurdly unlikely (and, thus far, umimaginable) senario that a woman's life depended on her child's skull being crushed after it was already outside of her, it is the responsibility of the court to not hold the doctor involved liable for deviating from the law in that one, unspeakably rare, incidient.
The Court has always held that just because a law could hypothetically, in some freakishly bizarre twist of chance, turn out badly, that does not make it a bad law.



I still havne't seen any. Post #111 offered no explination of how killing the fetus outside the womb was in any way useful to the woman. If you think I've misunderstood it, please clarify how the act of crushing the fetus' skull after it emerged was beneficial to the woman.
Or if you were speaking of a different post, I apologize for missing it, can you please direct me to it?
Well you know what you could do if you wanted to know what the defense some of these doctors offered was? You could do a little research. It is incredibly easy in this age of internet information.

I could do it for you but I'd like to prove a point.

You can't imagine a reason, and don't believe there is a reason yet never bother to hear a reason from those that are alleged professionals. That makes me think that you really don't want there to be a reason. Guess what, I don't either. There are a lot of horrible things I'd rather not face but that doesn't mean they don't exist.
__________________
...the government...is caving in...with their specious arguments couched in the...language of civil rights law, and that the churches ... likewise crumbling to...rhetoric which is nothing but heretical sophistry -- ~F Phelps
Platitudes like the one you offer are no different - and no less incorrect - than the jackass part-time Christian who says, "I'm going to heaven because I'm nice to people." It so misses the point.~Impugn
Reply With Quote