Quote:
Originally Posted by Mushroom
It was also a huge military-industrial complex. It was also the site of a slave camp. And one of the largest Officer School in the country.
Hiroshima Before the Bombing
Every military base has a large city "chock full of civilians". The Allied powers simply responded in kind when Germany-Japan turned it's attacks towards civilians in doing the same in return.
And look at the history of air attacks. There are numerous attacks that killed more then those 2 did.
And it is hard to have any sympathy, after events like Nanking.
Of course we could have not bombed them, and instead launched Operations Olympic and Coronet. Then we would have had 4-8 million dead, instead of less then 200,000.
|
Regardless of Hiroshima having some military targets, it was not necessary to use a nuclear device, that would have to target civilians more than the military targets.
There was no real reason for the atomic bombs to actually be used at all, much less using them on an evacuated demonstration target instead.
Nanking can't be used as a justification, because that was in 1937, and was not even enough cause for us to send arms to China, much less troops.